WordGPT

Two children, at least one is a boy

Exercise · Level 3 (Medium)

A family has two children and at least one is a boy. What is the probability that both are boys?

P(two boys∣at least one boy)= ?P(\text{two boys}\mid\text{at least one boy})=\ ?

wordgptpro.com

Solution

  1. The four equally likely families (older child first) are BB, BG, GB, GGBB,\ BG,\ GB,\ GG.

  2. 'At least one boy' removes GGGG, leaving three equally likely cases. Only one of them is two boys:

    P=13P=\frac13
    (1)
  3. It is not 12\tfrac12: if you are told that the older child is a boy, the cases left are BB,BGBB,BG and the answer would be 12\tfrac12. 'At least one' is weaker information.

Answer13\frac13

wordgptpro.com

Need a hint?

List all equally likely families (older, younger) and cross out those that do not fit.

The probability is 1/3: of the three families BB, BG, GB that have at least one boy, only BB has two boys.

How to work it out

  1. The four equally likely families (older child first) are BB, BG, GB, GGBB,\ BG,\ GB,\ GG.

  2. 'At least one boy' removes GGGG, leaving three equally likely cases. Only one of them is two boys:

    P=13P=\frac13
    (1)
  3. It is not 12\tfrac12: if you are told that the older child is a boy, the cases left are BB,BGBB,BG and the answer would be 12\tfrac12. 'At least one' is weaker information.

LaTeX source of the formulas on this page
\[ \frac13 \]
\[ P=\frac13 \]

Questions

What is the answer to: Two children, at least one is a boy?

The probability is 1/3: of the three families BB, BG, GB that have at least one boy, only BB has two boys.

What is the key idea?

Count the equally likely cases that fit the information, not just the cases for the second child.

Is there a hint?

List all equally likely families (older, younger) and cross out those that do not fit.

Related problems

More probability and puzzles

    Two children, at least one is a boy: answer and solution | WordGPT