WordGPT

Monty Hall: should you switch?

Exercise · Level 3 (Medium)

A car is behind one of three doors, goats behind the other two. You pick a door; the host, who knows where the car is, opens another door with a goat and offers you to switch. Should you?

wordgptpro.com

Solution

  1. Your first pick is right with probability 13\tfrac13 and wrong with probability 23\tfrac23.

  2. If your pick was wrong (23\tfrac23), the car is behind one of the other two doors. The host must open the other goat door, so the last closed door has the car: switching wins.

  3. If your pick was right (13\tfrac13), switching loses.

    P(win by switching)=23,P(win by staying)=13\begin{aligned}&P(\text{win by switching})\\&=\frac23,\qquad P(\text{win by staying})\\&=\frac13\end{aligned}
    (1)
AnswerSwitch: it wins with probability 23\text{Switch: it wins with probability } \tfrac{2}{3}

wordgptpro.com

Need a hint?

Ask how likely your first pick was right, and what the host's move tells you about the rest.

Yes, switch: switching wins with probability 2/3, staying only 1/3.

How to work it out

  1. Your first pick is right with probability 13\tfrac13 and wrong with probability 23\tfrac23.

  2. If your pick was wrong (23\tfrac23), the car is behind one of the other two doors. The host must open the other goat door, so the last closed door has the car: switching wins.

  3. If your pick was right (13\tfrac13), switching loses.

    P(win by switching)=23,P(win by staying)=13\begin{aligned}&P(\text{win by switching})\\&=\frac23,\qquad P(\text{win by staying})\\&=\frac13\end{aligned}
    (1)
LaTeX source of the formulas on this page
\[ \text{Switch: it wins with probability } \tfrac{2}{3} \]
\[ P(\text{win by switching})=\frac23,\qquad P(\text{win by staying})=\frac13 \]

Questions

What is the answer to: Monty Hall: should you switch??

Yes, switch: switching wins with probability 2/3, staying only 1/3.

What is the key idea?

The host's move gives no new information about your first pick, so all the leftover probability moves to the other door.

Is there a hint?

Ask how likely your first pick was right, and what the host's move tells you about the rest.

Related problems

More probability and puzzles

    Monty Hall: should you switch?: answer and solution | WordGPT