Bertrand's box paradox
Need a hint?
Label the three gold coins and ask which of them you could be holding.
The probability is 2/3: the goldāgold box produces a gold coin twice as often as the mixed box.
How to work it out
There are three gold coins: in the goldāgold box and in the mixed box. Drawing a gold coin means you hold one of the three, each equally likely.
If it is or , the other coin is gold; if it is , the other is silver:
(1)It is not : the goldāgold box is twice as likely to give a gold coin as the mixed box.
LaTeX source of the formulas on this page
\[ \frac23 \] \[ P=\frac23 \]
Questions
What is the answer to: Bertrand's box paradox?
The probability is 2/3: the goldāgold box produces a gold coin twice as often as the mixed box.
What is the key idea?
Count coins, not boxes: the information selects a coin, and two of the three gold coins lie in the same box as another gold.
Is there a hint?
Label the three gold coins and ask which of them you could be holding.