WordGPT

Bertrand's box paradox

Exercise Ā· Level 3 (Medium)

Three boxes hold two gold coins, two silver coins, and one gold and one silver coin. You pick a box at random and draw a coin at random: it is gold. What is the probability that the other coin in the box is also gold?

P(other is gold∣gold drawn)= ?P(\text{other is gold}\mid\text{gold drawn})=\ ?

wordgptpro.com

Solution

  1. There are three gold coins: G1,G2G_1,G_2 in the gold–gold box and G3G_3 in the mixed box. Drawing a gold coin means you hold one of the three, each equally likely.

  2. If it is G1G_1 or G2G_2, the other coin is gold; if it is G3G_3, the other is silver:

    P=23P=\frac23
    (1)
  3. It is not 12\tfrac12: the gold–gold box is twice as likely to give a gold coin as the mixed box.

Answer23\frac23

wordgptpro.com

Need a hint?

Label the three gold coins and ask which of them you could be holding.

The probability is 2/3: the gold–gold box produces a gold coin twice as often as the mixed box.

How to work it out

  1. There are three gold coins: G1,G2G_1,G_2 in the gold–gold box and G3G_3 in the mixed box. Drawing a gold coin means you hold one of the three, each equally likely.

  2. If it is G1G_1 or G2G_2, the other coin is gold; if it is G3G_3, the other is silver:

    P=23P=\frac23
    (1)
  3. It is not 12\tfrac12: the gold–gold box is twice as likely to give a gold coin as the mixed box.

LaTeX source of the formulas on this page
\[ \frac23 \]
\[ P=\frac23 \]

Questions

What is the answer to: Bertrand's box paradox?

The probability is 2/3: the gold–gold box produces a gold coin twice as often as the mixed box.

What is the key idea?

Count coins, not boxes: the information selects a coin, and two of the three gold coins lie in the same box as another gold.

Is there a hint?

Label the three gold coins and ask which of them you could be holding.

Related problems

More probability and puzzles

    Bertrand's box paradox: answer and solution | WordGPT