WordGPT

There are only five Platonic solids

Exercise Β· Level 5 (Olympiad)

A Platonic solid has identical regular p-gon faces with q faces at every vertex. Show that only five pairs (p, q) are possible.

1p+1q>12\frac1p+\frac1q>\frac12

wordgptpro.com

Solution 1/2

  1. Every face has pp edges and every edge lies on two faces, so pF=2EpF=2E; every vertex has qq edges, so qV=2EqV=2E. Put V=2EqV=\tfrac{2E}q and F=2EpF=\tfrac{2E}p into Vβˆ’E+F=2V-E+F=2:

    2Eqβˆ’E+2Ep=21p+1q=12+1E>12\begin{aligned}\frac{2E}q-E+\frac{2E}p&=2\\\frac1p+\frac1q&=\frac12+\frac1E>\frac12\end{aligned}
    (1)

wordgptpro.com

Solution 2/2

  1. Multiply out: 2q+2p>pq2q+2p>pq, that is

    (pβˆ’2)(qβˆ’2)<4(p-2)(q-2)<4
    (2)
  2. With p,qβ‰₯3p,q\ge3 the only solutions are (3,3),(3,4),(4,3),(3,5),(5,3)(3,3),(3,4),(4,3),(3,5),(5,3): the tetrahedron, the octahedron, the cube, the icosahedron and the dodecahedron. For example (p,q)=(4,4)(p,q)=(4,4) gives 4<ΜΈ44\not<4: the squares tile a flat plane, not a solid.

Answer(pβˆ’2)(qβˆ’2)<4Β β‡’Β 5Β solids(p-2)(q-2)<4\ \Rightarrow\ 5\ \text{solids}

wordgptpro.com

Need a hint?

Count edges two ways and combine with V βˆ’ E + F = 2.

Combining V βˆ’ E + F = 2 with counting edges gives (p βˆ’ 2)(q βˆ’ 2) < 4, which has exactly five solutions: the five Platonic solids.

How to work it out

  1. Every face has pp edges and every edge lies on two faces, so pF=2EpF=2E; every vertex has qq edges, so qV=2EqV=2E. Put V=2EqV=\tfrac{2E}q and F=2EpF=\tfrac{2E}p into Vβˆ’E+F=2V-E+F=2:

    2Eqβˆ’E+2Ep=21p+1q=12+1E>12\begin{aligned}\frac{2E}q-E+\frac{2E}p&=2\\\frac1p+\frac1q&=\frac12+\frac1E>\frac12\end{aligned}
    (1)
  2. Multiply out: 2q+2p>pq2q+2p>pq, that is

    (pβˆ’2)(qβˆ’2)<4(p-2)(q-2)<4
    (2)
  3. With p,qβ‰₯3p,q\ge3 the only solutions are (3,3),(3,4),(4,3),(3,5),(5,3)(3,3),(3,4),(4,3),(3,5),(5,3): the tetrahedron, the octahedron, the cube, the icosahedron and the dodecahedron. For example (p,q)=(4,4)(p,q)=(4,4) gives 4<ΜΈ44\not<4: the squares tile a flat plane, not a solid.

LaTeX source of the formulas on this page
\[ (p-2)(q-2)<4\ \Rightarrow\ 5\ \text{solids} \]
\[ \begin{aligned}\frac{2E}q-E+\frac{2E}p&=2\\\frac1p+\frac1q&=\frac12+\frac1E>\frac12\end{aligned} \]
\[ (p-2)(q-2)<4 \]

Questions

What is the answer to: There are only five Platonic solids?

Combining V βˆ’ E + F = 2 with counting edges gives (p βˆ’ 2)(q βˆ’ 2) < 4, which has exactly five solutions: the five Platonic solids.

What is the key idea?

Euler's formula forces 1/p + 1/q to be larger than 1/2, which leaves five pairs.

Is there a hint?

Count edges two ways and combine with V βˆ’ E + F = 2.

Related problems

More geometry problems

    There are only five Platonic solids: answer and solution | WordGPT