WordGPT

Archimedes bounds ฯ€ between 3 10/71 and 3 1/7

Exercise ยท Level 5 (Olympiad)

Archimedes squeezed ฯ€ between the perimeters of regular polygons inside and outside the circle. Repeat the doubling from hexagons up to 96 sides.

a2n=2anbnan+bn,b2n=a2nโ€‰bn\begin{aligned}&a_{2n}\\&=\frac{2a_nb_n}{a_n+b_n},\qquad b_{2n}\\&=\sqrt{a_{2n}\,b_n}\end{aligned}

wordgptpro.com

Solution

  1. For the unit circle the hexagons give a6=23โ‰ˆ3.4641a_6=2\sqrt3โ‰ˆ3.4641 (outer) and b6=3b_6=3 (inner). Doubling the number of sides: the new outer value is the harmonic mean of the old two, and the new inner value is the geometric mean of the new outer value and the old inner one.

  2. Applying this four times:

    nbnan123.10583.2154243.13263.1597483.13943.1461963.141033.14271\begin{array}{c|cc}n&b_n&a_n\\\hline12&3.1058&3.2154\\24&3.1326&3.1597\\48&3.1394&3.1461\\96&3.14103&3.14271\end{array}
    (1)
  3. So 3.14103<ฯ€<3.142713.14103<\pi<3.14271. Archimedes used fractions and rounded outwards, which gives his famous bounds:

    3.1408<ฯ€<3.14293.1408<\pi<3.1429
    (2)
Answer31071<ฯ€<3173\tfrac{10}{71}<\pi<3\tfrac17

wordgptpro.com

Need a hint?

Let aโ‚™ be half the perimeter of the outer n-gon and bโ‚™ half the perimeter of the inner n-gon (circle of radius 1). Start from the hexagon.

With 96-sided polygons Archimedes proved 3 10/71 < ฯ€ < 3 1/7, that is 3.1408 < ฯ€ < 3.1429. It was the best estimate for over 1,000 years.

How to work it out

  1. For the unit circle the hexagons give a6=23โ‰ˆ3.4641a_6=2\sqrt3โ‰ˆ3.4641 (outer) and b6=3b_6=3 (inner). Doubling the number of sides: the new outer value is the harmonic mean of the old two, and the new inner value is the geometric mean of the new outer value and the old inner one.

  2. Applying this four times:

    nbnan123.10583.2154243.13263.1597483.13943.1461963.141033.14271\begin{array}{c|cc}n&b_n&a_n\\\hline12&3.1058&3.2154\\24&3.1326&3.1597\\48&3.1394&3.1461\\96&3.14103&3.14271\end{array}
    (1)
  3. So 3.14103<ฯ€<3.142713.14103<\pi<3.14271. Archimedes used fractions and rounded outwards, which gives his famous bounds:

    3.1408<ฯ€<3.14293.1408<\pi<3.1429
    (2)
LaTeX source of the formulas on this page
\[ 3\tfrac{10}{71}<\pi<3\tfrac17 \]
\[ \begin{array}{c|cc}n&b_n&a_n\\\hline12&3.1058&3.2154\\24&3.1326&3.1597\\48&3.1394&3.1461\\96&3.14103&3.14271\end{array} \]
\[ 3.1408<\pi<3.1429 \]

Questions

What is the answer to: Archimedes bounds ฯ€ between 3 10/71 and 3 1/7?

With 96-sided polygons Archimedes proved 3 10/71 < ฯ€ < 3 1/7, that is 3.1408 < ฯ€ < 3.1429. It was the best estimate for over 1,000 years.

What is the key idea?

A circle is squeezed between the perimeters of inner and outer polygons, and doubling the sides is a short formula.

Is there a hint?

Let aโ‚™ be half the perimeter of the outer n-gon and bโ‚™ half the perimeter of the inner n-gon (circle of radius 1). Start from the hexagon.

Related problems

More geometry problems

    Archimedes bounds ฯ€ between 3 10/71 and 3 1/7: answer and solution | WordGPT