WordGPT

Where is the mistake in the proof that 2 = 1?

Exercise · Level 1 (School)

Let a = b. Then a² = ab, a² − b² = ab − b², (a + b)(a − b) = b(a − b), so a + b = b, and 2b = b, so 2 = 1. Find the error.

a=b ⇒ 2=1 ?a=b\ \Rightarrow\ 2=1\ ?

wordgptpro.com

Solution

  1. Every step up to (a+b)(a−b)=b(a−b)(a+b)(a-b)=b(a-b) is correct. Then both sides are divided by a−ba-b.

  2. But a=ba=b, so a−b=0a-b=0, and dividing by zero is not allowed: the equation 0⋅(a+b)=0⋅b0\cdot(a+b)=0\cdot b is true for all values and says nothing about a+ba+b and bb.

    0⋅(a+b)=0⋅b ̸⇒ a+b=b\begin{aligned}0\cdot(a+b)&=0\cdot b\ \not\\&\Rightarrow\ a+b=b\end{aligned}
    (1)
AnswerDivision by a−b=0\text{Division by }a-b=0

wordgptpro.com

Need a hint?

Look at what is cancelled in the step from (a + b)(a − b) = b(a − b) to a + b = b.

The error is the division by a − b, which is 0 because a = b: you cannot cancel a zero factor.

How to work it out

  1. Every step up to (a+b)(a−b)=b(a−b)(a+b)(a-b)=b(a-b) is correct. Then both sides are divided by a−ba-b.

  2. But a=ba=b, so a−b=0a-b=0, and dividing by zero is not allowed: the equation 0⋅(a+b)=0⋅b0\cdot(a+b)=0\cdot b is true for all values and says nothing about a+ba+b and bb.

    0⋅(a+b)=0⋅b ̸⇒ a+b=b\begin{aligned}0\cdot(a+b)&=0\cdot b\ \not\\&\Rightarrow\ a+b=b\end{aligned}
    (1)
LaTeX source of the formulas on this page
\[ \text{Division by }a-b=0 \]
\[ 0\cdot(a+b)=0\cdot b\ \not\Rightarrow\ a+b=b \]

Questions

What is the answer to: Where is the mistake in the proof that 2 = 1??

The error is the division by a − b, which is 0 because a = b: you cannot cancel a zero factor.

What is the key idea?

A factor you cancel must not be zero.

Is there a hint?

Look at what is cancelled in the step from (a + b)(a − b) = b(a − b) to a + b = b.

Related problems

More algebra problems

    Where is the mistake in the proof that 2 = 1?: answer and solution | WordGPT